One More from the Attic Pt. 02

"Oh. Oh, God! I'm so embarrassed," Amy said. I could practically hear her blushing over the phone.

"I loved being with you, Amy," I said, "but if it comes down to me being with you or you being my sister's best friend, I want you to be her friend."

I heard Amy's voice crack. "You're so sweet," she said.

In front of me, my sister looked at me with love and admiration. It was like she was melting—but in a good way.

"Amy, would you please do me a favor?" I asked. "Call my sister so she can apologize to you. She feels terrible and really wants to make it up to you."

I felt like such a manipulative bastard when Amy called my sister minutes later. I mean, I knew that she desperately wanted to be with me again after the way I had given her so much pleasure the other night. She wanted to believe me, so she did. She eagerly accepted my sister's apology for the "misunderstanding." Half an hour after that, she was in our apartment, hugging my sister tightly in our living room. They both had tears in their eyes when they finally released each other.

I leaned in and kissed Amy on her cheek. "Thank you," I whispered. She threw her arms around my neck and pulled me down to her. "No, thank you!" She drove her tongue frantically into my mouth as she kissed me right in front of my sister. Hope smiled at me, then stood right behind Amy and gently rubbed her shoulders.

Amy's eyes were a little wild after that kiss. Hope turned her and asked, "Have you eaten? We were just about to have dinner." Amy shook her head. "Come on," my sister said with a smile. They held hands as Hope led her to our dining room table.

We shared a nice dinner. Amy and Hope talked about their classes, occasionally letting me join in when our French class came up. I just smiled at both of them most of that meal. Twice, Amy reached over and impulsively squeezed my hand. Both times, she repeated the gesture with Hope immediately afterward.

We sat on the couch and turned on the television, even though none of us were paying attention to what was on. Amy sat on my lap and immediately turned around so she could kiss me while writhing on top of me. Hope leaned in and kissed Amy on her cheek. "You two look amazing together," she breathed. She sighed and added, "I'll give you two some privacy," and started to get up.

"No!" Amy gasped, pulling her mouth from me. "You should stay." She only blushed a little when she softly added, "I want you to be here with us."

Amy was all over me after that. Hope was clearly aroused watching us. Eventually, she cleared her throat. "That looks a little uncomfortable. You guys can use my bed if you'd like. There's a lot more room in there."

"Yes!" Amy gasped, but of course she dragged Hope along with us.

Amy was on fire when she kicked off her jeans while kissing me. We were still kissing as she lay back on Hope's bed. Hope stood beside the bed and watched until Amy broke off the kiss and looked over at her. "It's okay, Hope," she said, patting the mattress next to her. "You should lie down and get comfortable. Oh!" Her eyes went wide and she looked back at me as I kissed my way down her tummy.

Hope slid into the bed as I pulled Amy's panties aside and gently licked her soaking pussy. My sister reached over and held Amy's hand gently. Amy was the one who intertwined their fingers and squeezed my sister's hand. "That looks incredible," Hope breathed.

"Oh god!" Amy gasped. Then she pulled Hope's head down and started kissing her. Hope's eyes went wide. Amy frantically kissed my sister for several seconds before Hope "reluctantly" moaned and kissed her back. Amy shuddered and came, moaning sexily into my sister's soft mouth.

She lifted her hips for me so I could slide her panties off of her. As soon as I slid my hard cock into her drenched pussy, I whispered, "You two look so damned hot!" Amy started tugging at Hope's clothes as I slowly fucked her. Hope stripped down to her panties and lay next to Amy, and they kissed hungrily while Amy fondled my sister's big breasts.

I lifted Amy's right leg and slowly turned her onto her side with my cock buried inside her. Hope broke off their kiss and she stroked Amy's cheek. Then Hope gasped, "Oh, Amy! You shouldn't...oh!" She breathed heavily for a while before groaning, "That feels so nice." Amy had taken one of my sister's thick nipples into her mouth and she was slurping on her breast noisily. I was not even thrusting into Amy's tight little snatch. I felt her pussy fluttering and soaking me with her juices over and over. She was so aroused just from having me inside her while she molested my sister.

I leaned over her body and whispered "Wow" into her ear. Then I kissed her neck. Both of them were moaning as Amy eagerly sucked Hope's sensitive nipples. My sister pulled her panties to the side, showing me how drenched she was and sliding one finger inside. I pulled my cock out of Amy, making her groan. Then I knelt behind her and pulled her up onto her knees. That caused her to release Hope's nipple, and it also pushed Hope onto her back.

I pulled Amy's hips toward me, impaling her pussy on my throbbing dick once again. She moaned and kissed her way down Hope's body as I did it. I drove my cock into her, and that pushed Amy's gasping mouth right into my sister's waiting pussy. "Oh, no! What are you doing?" Hope moaned. "Amy, please, you can't lick me there! Oh! Oh, please! You've got to stop or I'm going to—OH! Oh, God, I'm coming!"

That last part was no act. My sister shook as she came all over her best friend's sucking mouth. Amy shook through her own intense orgasm. It was too much stimulation for me. The way that little blonde pussy looked stretched around my cock, the way her shapely little ass shook as she came, the way Hope's tits shook and bobbed as she came..."Amy, I'm going to come!" I cried out.

"Mmm-hmm!" she groaned into Hope's pussy. She finally pulled her mouth from my sister and looked over her shoulder long enough to gasp, "Come inside me!" Then she dove back into Hope's pussy and sucked on my sister's horny, throbbing clit.

Amy actually apologized to us afterwards. She was completely convinced that everything that we had done that night was because she made it happen. She kissed Hope again and again as we all lay naked in that bed. "Oh, Hope, I hope you're not mad at me." Kiss. "I know this isn't what you really wanted. I just love you so much." Kiss. "I'm so happy you let me be with your brother, and I just wanted to share this moment with you. Please don't be mad at me."

Hope kissed her back tenderly. "Oh, Amy, I'm not mad at you at all. You just really surprised me, that's all." Hope kissed her again, tenderly, and her hand found Amy's sensitive breast. "May I?" she asked, lowering her mouth to that pale nipple.

"Ohhh, yes!" Amy groaned appreciatively.

Hope feasted on Amy's sensitive breasts and pushed her back toward me. My renewed erection slid easily into Amy's drooling pussy, and she moaned in almost continuous climax between us until she passed out. I felt Hope's fingers exploring the juncture of my cock and Amy's pussy. She wanted to make sure I slept with my dick inside Amy.

The next morning—way too early—I found out why. Amy had to get up at 3:30 to get ready for her morning shift at Denny's. She kissed Hope and then me, groaning as my cock slid out of her. She got out of the bed and took a quick shower before heading out the door. I think she was trying to let us get back to sleep. As soon as the door closed behind her, Hope dove onto my sloppy cock and sucked it with gusto.

"God, I wanted to do this all night," she gasped between slurps. "Every time you pulled out of her pussy, I wanted to lick her and suck you."

I watched her gobble my dick for a couple of minutes before I spoke up. "Now you just have to make sure you don't sound too eager when she asks to come back over."

I was really too tired to give my horny sister what she desperately wanted. She rode me hard, and I kept dozing off. She managed to get herself off while riding my dick, but it wasn't as satisfying as sex normally was for us. She rolled off of me and pulled the covers over us. "Hey," she whispered.

"Yeah?" I mumbled.

"You owe me a real fuck in the morning."

"Okay."

Four hours later, I gave it to her. I pounded her sweet pussy all over that bed. We showered and I fucked her horny asshole afterward, bending her over the side of the bed. I couldn't help but imagine Danielle's ass, with my sister's saliva coating it, when I first slid into her tight little rectal ring. We ran out of time before I got to come, but at least I had satisfied Hope before she left for work.

* * *

Amy called me right after Hope left for work. She was nervous and apologetic.

"Daniel, I am so sorry," she gushed. "I don't know what came over me last night."

"Amy, it's alright. I wasn't ever upset, just surprised. Hope seemed a little freaked out, but I think that was as much about waking up naked in bed with her brother as it was about what happened last night."

"Oh, God! I didn't even think about that!"

"I calmed her down, though. I mean, it's not like she and I had sex last night. She said she felt guilty, but she really enjoyed it when you kissed her."

"Oh. She did?"

"Yes. We agreed that you are an amazing kisser, Amy." Again, I could almost hear her blush over the phone.

"Thanks," she murmured.

"Hope was obviously a little...confused," I went on. "I don't think she ever had a girl kiss her like that before. She certainly never expected you to kiss her...everywhere like that. But when I asked her about it, she had to admit she really enjoyed it. She blushed when I told her how amazing the two of you looked and how turned on you got me."

"I could tell," she whispered.

"Besides," I continued, "it's not like we were drunk or anything. We were just three adults who got really turned on and pushed our boundaries a little bit. Nobody got hurt. We'll just tone it down a little bit the next time we're together."

"Oh, thank god," Amy breathed. "I am so glad to hear you say that. I was so worried you would think I was some kind of freak, but at the same time I was worried that you might expect me to do more of that. I'm not sure I could deal with either one of those...um...outcomes? No, that's not right. Anyway, I'm so glad you understand."

"I can't wait to see you again," I said. "Do you think I could see you at lunch today?"

* * *

Lunch wasn't feasible, but we did get together on campus at 2:30 in the afternoon for a brief visit. Amy looked nervous until I smiled and hugged her tightly. She melted against my chest. I rubbed her back and felt her relax as I kissed the top of her head.

"You look great," I said as we sat on a bench.

"Thanks," she said. "I felt like a nervous wreck all morning. I could barely look at Hope in our morning class, much less talk to her."

"That's a shame," I said. "I'm sure she is just as nervous about talking to you."

"What do I say, though?" she asked.

"Honestly? Just act like last night never happened. At least until you know you guys are okay, and you've had some time to think about it. Once you get past that, you guys have lots to talk about."

She looked at my face closely. "Daniel...why aren't you freaked out about any of this?"

I swallowed a little nervously at that. Shit! Had I blown this? "What do you mean?"

"Well, I was freaked out, and Hope was freaked out. You seem way too calm about everything."

I felt my face heating up, and knew that I was blushing. I thought quickly. "Amy...I don't want you to think I'm some kind of pervert or anything. If I tell you this, it has got to be a secret between you and me. If it makes you want to break up with me, I'll understand, but you have to promise you will never tell anybody."

"Even Hope?" she asked.

"Especially not Hope," I said. That had her undivided attention. She nodded. "You've got to swear, you will never tell anyone," I said.

"I swear," she replied readily.

"Okay," I said. I shook my head. "I can't believe I'm telling you this." I chewed my lip as I tried to figure out exactly how to put this. "You know how you thought it was odd when Hope sat in my lap, that first time you came over?"

She nodded, and I went on. "Well that started almost a year ago. Hope sat in my lap while our family watched television one night. It wasn't a big deal. Then she did it more often. Colleen, our older sister, started doing it too. The thing is, I've always known my sisters are beautiful. All my life I saw the way guys stared at them. Suddenly, here I was, this horny eighteen-year-old—"

Amy covered her mouth and her eyes were wide. She tried not to giggle, but it came through. I looked at her and spread my hands helplessly.

"Yeah," I said. "I was getting turned on from my own sisters sitting in my lap. Nothing ever happened, of course, but I got turned on and I have to admit, I fantasized about something happening. I always felt guilty about it." I gave her a moment for that to sink in. "So, when I finally got to see my sister naked last night, it was like a fantasy come true. She's my sister, and I would never do anything to hurt her, but you felt how hard I got inside you when you got her to undress. I got even more turned on when you two were...you know."

It was Amy's turn to blush then. I reached out and squeezed her hand. "I've been hiding that from her for so long," I said. "I was terrified they would feel me getting hard when they sat in my lap. I've just kept all of that deep inside and acted like I was calm and cool with everything."

"I see," Amy said softly.

"I was nervous the first time you and I were together," I lied, "but obviously you didn't think I was. Hope was freaked out when we woke up naked in her bed, but I acted calm and managed to calm her down. We got dressed, and then we talked about you."

"Do you still think about Hope like that?" Amy asked softly. "When she sits in your lap, does it still...?"

I thought about it for a bit. "She's my sister," I said with a shrug. "I love her, and that's what counts. I could never do anything that would hurt her like that." Then I looked down and whispered, "But, yeah, I still get hard when she sits in my lap. Every time."

"Oh," Amy breathed. I looked back up at her face. She was flushed.

"You promised," I reminded her. "You can never tell her any of this."

"Oh, I won't," Amy said.

* * *

Hope and Amy apparently did talk that afternoon. The two of them came to the apartment together late that evening, and we shared another nice dinner. After dinner the three of us again went to the couch, and I sat between them. I was surprised when Amy spoke up.

"Hope, why don't you sit in Daniel's lap this time?" she suggested. I turned and looked at her sharply. She looked just a little too innocent as she kept her eyes locked on the television. I turned and realized that Hope was also staring at Amy. My sister looked at me and licked her lips nervously before she slid into my lap.

We caught the second half of a movie that was on network television. It was something all of us had seen before, but I wasn't paying enough attention to tell you now what it was. I was desperately trying to get a read on my sister and Amy.

Amy looked over at us a few times. Each time she had an enigmatic little smile on her lips. Hope's crotch felt very warm, and soon got me hard even though I was trying not to get turned on. Hope let out a little moan when she felt it, and that earned us another brief look and smile from Amy.

After the movie, Amy turned to us. "I don't have to work in the morning. Would you guys mind if I stay with you tonight and snuggle between you again?" Hope and I exchanged a nervous look, and she quickly added, "Not naked, of course! We'll sleep in t-shirts and underwear so nothing crazy happens."

"Um...okay," Hope said. I shrugged. When Hope got up out of my lap, Amy looked at my bulging cock and smiled before looking up at my face.

"Why don't you go get changed and then you can join us?" Amy suggested. I nodded and went to my room, getting a clean t-shirt and boxers and slipping into them.

I walked into my sister's room just as Amy broke off kissing my sister. This had been a soft kiss on the lips. I couldn't help but look at my sister's hard nipples poking out of the front of that t-shirt. I think Amy saw me looking there, and I tried to play it off. I slid into the far side of the bed closest to the wall. Amy crawled onto the bed next to me.

"Turn this way," she said.

I did, and then she faced Hope and pushed her back against me. Her tight little butt was right in my crotch. Hope turned down the lamp so that the room was left in dim illumination, and then she slid into the bed on the other side of Amy. Amy wiggled her butt against me until my hard cock was lodged between her cheeks and then she sighed.

"That's so nice," she breathed. "Thank you guys so much for being so understanding. I'm so happy to be right here tonight."

"I'm glad you're here," Hope whispered.

"Good night," Amy whispered back. She kissed Hope softly on the lips, and moaned when she felt my cock buck against her bottom. "Oh. That feels so good."

I realized that she was talking to Hope, not me. Suddenly I thought I had an idea what was going on. Hope had confided something to her, as I had. Amy knew that there was an attraction between us. She was trying to make something happen between me and Hope. I smiled at that, and my body relaxed. Oh, my dick was still completely hard, but the rest of me wasn't stiff anymore. I kissed the back of Amy's neck a couple of times, then rested my head on the pillow and went to sleep.